EMMA HARRIS, ET AL. v. AMANDA B. ALDMON, ET AL. E2014-00203-COA-R3-CV Court Case Public Record

  • Details

    Case TitleEMMA HARRIS, ET AL. v. AMANDA B. ALDMON, ET AL.
    Case NumberE2014-00203-COA-R3-CV
    Case TypeAppellate Case
    StateTennessee, TN
    CountyKnox County
    CourtKnox County Chancery Court
    Court AddressAdministrative Office of the Courts 511 Union Street, Suite 600 Nashville, TN 37219
    Phone(615) 741-2687 | (800) 448-7970
    Field Date05/07/2014
    Close Date02/03/2014
  • Parties

    CounselNameType
    Smith, Thomas Kenan
    Harris, Emma
    Appellant/Plaintiff
    Smith, Thomas Kenan
    Smith-Lindsey Development, LLC
    Appellant/Plaintiff
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Aldmon, Amanda B.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Seymour Jr., Arthur Gloster
    Whaley, Robert A.
    Appellant/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Bommelje, Sarah M.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Christian, Bryan J.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Combs, Sarah J.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Cooper, Julia B.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Cragle, Donna L.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Durfee, Alan Christopher
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Eimers, Carol E.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Hammer, Alvin Butler
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Hammond, Marilyn B.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Helton, Timothy S.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Henegar, Ruth
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Hill, Nelda A.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Hornbaker, William S.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Horton, Bettye Kolter
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Howell, Jimmy L.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Keith, Beverly Humphreys
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Klimek, John B.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Leidig, Mary Beth
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Lind, Carol L.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Muffler, Mary K.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Muffler, Steven
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Prosser, Joan
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Riggs, Carolyn Ogg
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Thomas, Joyce Anna
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Weigenstein, Timothy E.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Zinavage, Carol
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Hornbaker, Margaret
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Thomas, Charles
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Aldmon, Thomas G.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Bales, Cheryl Ann
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Bales, Stephen R.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Beal, Alan C.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Beal, Karen
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Bell, Herbert A.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Bell, Wanda H.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Brennan, James A.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Brennan, Mary K.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Cavanaugh, Eugene F.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Cavanaugh, Connie
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Chady, Markus E.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Chady, Erin S.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Cloninger, Kenneth A.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Cloninger, Kathy O.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Currie, Stuart
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Currie, Donna
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Dickinson, Paul A.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Dickinson, Nancy S.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Galyon Jr., Paul E.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Galyon, Mary Jane
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Horner, Jason W.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Horner, Christine N.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Huffman, James H.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Huffman, Judy
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Lopez, Synda M.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Lopez, Pedro P.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    McCullock, Kim L.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    McCullock, Shannon P.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Obenschain, Lesli A.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Obenschain, Charles G.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Pena, Jose C.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Pena, Kristen E.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Ridner, Corey A.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Ridner, Te P.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Trivette, Judith Needham
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Trivette, Jerry
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Williamson, Anona D.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Williamson, Stan M.
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Andrew, Barbara
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    McDonald, Lowell
    Appellee/Defendant
    Rhea, Dan Douglas
    McDonald, Sammye
    Appellee/Defendant
  • Case Overview
    Style Trial Court Trial Court Judge Trial Court No. Inter. Case No.
    EMMA HARRIS, ET AL. v. AMANDA B. ALDMON, ET AL. Knox County Chancery Court Moyers, Michael W. 1808432
  • Case Milestones
    Description Date
    Appeal Filed 02/03/2014
    Record Filed 05/07/2014
    Appellant(s) Briefing Complete 07/07/2014
    Appellee(s) Briefing Complete 09/05/2014
    Oral Argument/Submission 10/29/2014
    Panel 03/30/2015
    Decision Date Opinion
    Decision Type Affirmed in Part, Reversed in Part
    Disposition 07/13/2015
    Appeal to S. Ct. Date
    Closed Date
  • Parties
    Names Role Counsel
    Harris, Emma Appellant/Plaintiff Smith, Thomas Kenan
    Smith-Lindsey Development, LLC Appellant/Plaintiff Smith, Thomas Kenan
    Aldmon, Amanda B. Appellee/Defendant Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Whaley, Robert A. Appellant/Defendant Seymour Jr., Arthur Gloster
    Bommelje, Sarah M. Appellee/Defendant Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Christian, Bryan J. Appellee/Defendant Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Combs, Sarah J. Appellee/Defendant Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Cooper, Julia B. Appellee/Defendant Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Cragle, Donna L. Appellee/Defendant Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Durfee, Alan Christopher Appellee/Defendant Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Eimers, Carol E. Appellee/Defendant Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Hammer, Alvin Butler Appellee/Defendant Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Hammond, Marilyn B. Appellee/Defendant Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Helton, Timothy S. Appellee/Defendant Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Henegar, Ruth Appellee/Defendant Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Hill, Nelda A. Appellee/Defendant Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Hornbaker, William S. Appellee/Defendant Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Horton, Bettye Kolter Appellee/Defendant Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Howell, Jimmy L. Appellee/Defendant Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Keith, Beverly Humphreys Appellee/Defendant Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Klimek, John B. Appellee/Defendant Rhea, Dan Douglas
    Leidig, Mary Beth Appellee/Defendant Rhea, Dan Douglas
  • Case History
    Date Event Filer PDF
    07/13/2015 Appellate Record-Sent to Local Archive Harris, Emma (Appellant/Plaintiff); Smith-Lindsey Development, LLC (Appellant/Plaintiff) PDF PDF
    07/13/2015 Mandate-Issued Aldmon, Amanda B. (Appellee/Defendant); Aldmon, Thomas G. (Appellee/Defendant); Andrew, Barbara (Appellee/Defendant); Bales, Cheryl Ann (Appellee/Defendant); Bales, Stephen R. (Appellee/Defendant); Beal, Alan C. (Appellee/Defendant); Beal, Karen (Appellee/Defendant); Bell, Herbert A. (Appellee/Defendant); Bell, Wanda H. (Appellee/Defendant); Bommelje, Sarah M. (Appellee/Defendant); Brennan, James A. (Appellee/Defendant); Brennan, Mary K. (Appellee/Defendant); Cavanaugh, Connie (Appellee/Defendant); Cavanaugh, Eugene F. (Appellee/Defendant); Chady, Erin S. (Appellee/Defendant); Chady, Markus E. (Appellee/Defendant); Christian, Bryan J. (Appellee/Defendant); Cloninger, Kathy O. (Appellee/Defendant); Cloninger, Kenneth A. (Appellee/Defendant); Combs, Sarah J. (Appellee/Defendant); Cooper, Julia B. (Appellee/Defendant); Cragle, Donna L. (Appellee/Defendant); Currie, Donna (Appellee/Defendant); Currie, Stuart (Appellee/Defendant); Dickinson, Nancy S. (Appellee/Defendant); Dickinson, Paul A. (Appellee/Defendant); Durfee, Alan Christopher (Appellee/Defendant); Eimers, Carol E. (Appellee/Defendant); Galyon Jr., Paul E. (Appellee/Defendant); Galyon, Mary Jane (Appellee/Defendant); Hammer, Alvin Butler (Appellee/Defendant); Hammond, Marilyn B. (Appellee/Defendant); Helton, Timothy S. (Appellee/Defendant); Henegar, Ruth (Appellee/Defendant); Hill, Nelda A. (Appellee/Defendant); Hornbaker, Margaret (Appellee/Defendant); Hornbaker, William S. (Appellee/Defendant); Horner, Christine N. (Appellee/Defendant); Horner, Jason W. (Appellee/Defendant); Horton, Bettye Kolter (Appellee/Defendant); Howell, Jimmy L. (Appellee/Defendant); Huffman, James H. (Appellee/Defendant); Huffman, Judy (Appellee/Defendant); Keith, Beverly Humphreys (Appellee/Defendant); Klimek, John B. (Appellee/Defendant); Leidig, Mary Beth
    04/21/2015 Order-Petition to Rehear Granted Rhea, Dan Douglas (Attorney)
    04/08/2015 Response-to Petition to Rehear Dan Douglas Rhea
    04/07/2015 Petition-to Rehear Whaley, Robert A. (Appellant/Defendant)
    03/30/2015 Opinion-Filed Harris, Emma (Appellant/Plaintiff); Smith-Lindsey Development, LLC (Appellant/Plaintiff)
    03/30/2015 Appellate Record-Checked In from Court Aldmon, Amanda B. (Appellee/Defendant); Aldmon, Thomas G. (Appellee/Defendant); Andrew, Barbara (Appellee/Defendant); Bales, Cheryl Ann (Appellee/Defendant); Bales, Stephen R. (Appellee/Defendant); Beal, Alan C. (Appellee/Defendant); Beal, Karen (Appellee/Defendant); Bell, Herbert A. (Appellee/Defendant); Bell, Wanda H. (Appellee/Defendant); Bommelje, Sarah M. (Appellee/Defendant); Brennan, James A. (Appellee/Defendant); Brennan, Mary K. (Appellee/Defendant); Cavanaugh, Connie (Appellee/Defendant); Cavanaugh, Eugene F. (Appellee/Defendant); Chady, Erin S. (Appellee/Defendant); Chady, Markus E. (Appellee/Defendant); Christian, Bryan J. (Appellee/Defendant); Cloninger, Kathy O. (Appellee/Defendant); Cloninger, Kenneth A. (Appellee/Defendant); Combs, Sarah J. (Appellee/Defendant); Cooper, Julia B. (Appellee/Defendant); Cragle, Donna L. (Appellee/Defendant); Currie, Donna (Appellee/Defendant); Currie, Stuart (Appellee/Defendant); Dickinson, Nancy S. (Appellee/Defendant); Dickinson, Paul A. (Appellee/Defendant); Durfee, Alan Christopher (Appellee/Defendant); Eimers, Carol E. (Appellee/Defendant); Galyon Jr., Paul E. (Appellee/Defendant); Galyon, Mary Jane (Appellee/Defendant); Hammer, Alvin Butler (Appellee/Defendant); Hammond, Marilyn B. (Appellee/Defendant); Helton, Timothy S. (Appellee/Defendant); Henegar, Ruth (Appellee/Defendant); Hill, Nelda A. (Appellee/Defendant); Hornbaker, Margaret (Appellee/Defendant); Hornbaker, William S. (Appellee/Defendant); Horner, Christine N. (Appellee/Defendant); Horner, Jason W. (Appellee/Defendant); Horton, Bettye Kolter (Appellee/Defendant); Howell, Jimmy L. (Appellee/Defendant); Huffman, James H. (Appellee/Defendant); Huffman, Judy (Appellee/Defendant); Keith, Beverly Humphreys (Appellee/Defendant); Klimek, John B. (Appellee/Defendant); Leidig, Mary Beth
    10/24/2014 Appellate Record-Checked Out to Court Whaley, Robert A. (Appellant/Defendant)
    10/03/2014 Docket Activity-Attorney Confirmed Oral Argument Taylor Daniel Forrester
    09/30/2014 Docket Activity-Attorney Confirmed Oral Argument Arthur Gloster Seymour, Jr.
    09/29/2014 Docket Activity-Attorney Confirmed Oral Argument Taylor Daniel Forrester
    09/26/2014 Docket Activity-Docketed (Oral Argument) Harris, Emma (Appellant/Plaintiff); Smith-Lindsey Development, LLC (Appellant/Plaintiff)
    09/18/2014 Brief-Reply Brief Filed Whaley, Robert A. (Appellant/Defendant)
    09/18/2014 Appellate Record-Checked In Harris, Emma (Appellant/Plaintiff); Smith-Lindsey Development, LLC (Appellant/Plaintiff)
    09/10/2014 Appellate Record-Checked Out Thomas Kenan Smith
    09/05/2014 Case Status-APPELLEE BRIEFING COMPLETE Whaley, Robert A. (Appellee/Defendant)
    09/05/2014 Brief-Appellee's Brief Filed Harris, Emma (Appellant/Plaintiff); Smith-Lindsey Development, LLC (Appellant/Plaintiff)
    09/05/2014 Appellate Record-Checked In Aldmon, Amanda B. (Appellee/Defendant); Aldmon, Tom and Amanda (Appellee/Defendant); Andrew, Barbara (Appellee/Defendant); Bales, Stephen and Cheryl Ann (Appellee/Defendant); Beal, Alan and Karen (Appellee/Defendant); Bell, Herbert and Wanda (Appellee/Defendant); Bommelje, Sarah (Appellee/Defendant); Brennan, James and Mary K. (Appellee/Defendant); Cavanaugh, Eugene and Connie (Appellee/Defendant); Chady, Markus and Erin (Appellee/Defendant); Christian, Bryan (Appellee/Defendant); Cloninger, Kenneth and Kathy (Appellee/Defendant); Combs, Sarah J. (Appellee/Defendant); Cooper, Julia (Appellee/Defendant); Cragle, Donna (Appellee/Defendant); Currie, Stuart and Donna (Appellee/Defendant); Dickinson, Paul and Nancy (Appellee/Defendant); Durfee, Alan (Appellee/Defendant); Elmers, Carol (Appellee/Defendant); Galyon, Paul and Mary Jane (Appellee/Defendant); Hammer, Alvin (Appellee/Defendant); Hammond, Marilyn (Appellee/Defendant); Helton, Timothy (Appellee/Defendant); Henegar, Ruth (Appellee/Defendant); Hill, Nelda A. (Appellee/Defendant); Hornbaker, Margaret (Appellee/Defendant); Hornbaker, William (Appellee/Defendant); Horner, Jason and Christie (Appellee/Defendant); Horton, Bettye (Appellee/Defendant); Howell, Jimmy (Appellee/Defendant); Huffman, James and Judy (Appellee/Defendant); Keith, Beverly (Appellee/Defendant); Klimek, John (Appellee/Defendant); Leidig, Mary Beth (Appellee/Defendant); Lind, Carol (Appellee/Defendant); Lopez, Synda and Pedro (Appellee/Defendant); McCullock, Kim and Shannon (Appellee/Defendant); McDonald, Lowell and Sammye (Appellee/Defendant); Muffler, Mary K. (Appellee/Defendant); Muffler, Steven (Appellee/Defendant); Obenschain, Lesli and Charles (Appellee/Defendant); Pena, Jose and Kirsten (Appellee/Defendant); Prosser, Joan (Appellee/Defendant); Ridner, Corey and Te P. (Appe
    08/28/2014 Appellate Record-Supplemental Filed Aldmon, Amanda B. (Appellee/Defendant); Aldmon, Thomas G. (Appellee/Defendant); Andrew, Barbara (Appellee/Defendant); Bales, Cheryl Ann (Appellee/Defendant); Bales, Stephen R. (Appellee/Defendant); Beal, Alan C. (Appellee/Defendant); Beal, Karen (Appellee/Defendant); Bell, Herbert A. (Appellee/Defendant); Bell, Wanda H. (Appellee/Defendant); Bommelje, Sarah M. (Appellee/Defendant); Brennan, James A. (Appellee/Defendant); Brennan, Mary K. (Appellee/Defendant); Cavanaugh, Connie (Appellee/Defendant); Cavanaugh, Eugene F. (Appellee/Defendant); Chady, Erin S. (Appellee/Defendant); Chady, Markus E. (Appellee/Defendant); Christian, Bryan J. (Appellee/Defendant); Cloninger, Kathy O. (Appellee/Defendant); Cloninger, Kenneth A. (Appellee/Defendant); Combs, Sarah J. (Appellee/Defendant); Cooper, Julia B. (Appellee/Defendant); Cragle, Donna L. (Appellee/Defendant); Currie, Donna (Appellee/Defendant); Currie, Stuart (Appellee/Defendant); Dickinson, Nancy S. (Appellee/Defendant); Dickinson, Paul A. (Appellee/Defendant); Durfee, Alan Christopher (Appellee/Defendant); Eimers, Carol E. (Appellee/Defendant); Galyon Jr., Paul E. (Appellee/Defendant); Galyon, Mary Jane (Appellee/Defendant); Hammer, Alvin Butler (Appellee/Defendant); Hammond, Marilyn B. (Appellee/Defendant); Helton, Timothy S. (Appellee/Defendant); Henegar, Ruth (Appellee/Defendant); Hill, Nelda A. (Appellee/Defendant); Hornbaker, Margaret (Appellee/Defendant); Hornbaker, William S. (Appellee/Defendant); Horner, Christine N. (Appellee/Defendant); Horner, Jason W. (Appellee/Defendant); Horton, Bettye Kolter (Appellee/Defendant); Howell, Jimmy L. (Appellee/Defendant); Huffman, James H. (Appellee/Defendant); Huffman, Judy (Appellee/Defendant); Keith, Beverly Humphreys (Appellee/Defendant); Klimek, John B. (Appellee/Defendant); Leidig, Mary Beth
    08/25/2014 Appellate Record-Supplemental Received Whaley, Robert (Appellee/Defendant)
    08/18/2014 Order-Supplement to Record Harris, Emma (Appellant/Plaintiff); Smith-Lindsey Development, LLC (Appellant/Plaintiff)
    08/06/2014 Order Related to Extension-Granted
  • Record Information
    Volume Type Volumes Record Type
    Technical Record 1 Supplemental
    Exhibits 1 Supplemental
    Technical Record 1 Supplemental
    Exhibits 4 Supplemental
    Technical Record 7 Original
    Transcript of Evidence 3 Original
    Exhibits 42 Original